Clean Rooms Are Sold as Privacy Protection. Qonsent's Jesse Redniss Says Clean Rooms Don't Clean Data.
By Pesach Lattin, from The ADOTAT Show
Jesse Redniss worked on enterprise data strategy at WarnerMedia before co-founding Qonsent, which builds plain-language permission experiences for brands. On The ADOTAT Show he explained why consent has to be collected before data ever reaches a clean room.
What was said
- “Clean rooms don't clean data. You can't put a bunch of garbage into a clean room and expect to just be able to transact on it.”
On the biggest myth about clean rooms - “A simple yes or no blunt choice, not really providing the consumer with any context or true agency over what choices they're making.”
On the Apple tracking prompt - “You don't have to be afraid to be transparent with what you're actually doing with people's data.”
On a QR code consent program with an 85 percent opt-in rate - “If you know a kid is on the other end watching Sesame Street, and then an hour later it's watching something rated R, you've got to be really careful with how that device information or that IP address is then utilized.”
On household IP targeting on CTV
Why it matters
A clean room controls how data is matched. It does not tell you whether the people in it agreed to that use. That record has to exist before the data goes in, which is why Redniss keeps returning to provenance. His CTV example raises the harder version of the same problem: a household IP address mixes adults and children on one device, and targeting built on it can carry children's privacy risk nobody intended.
Questions to ask before you sign
- For each dataset in our clean room, where is the record of what the consumer agreed to?
- Did any incentive offer we ran collect personal data without the explicit consent some states require?
- Does our CTV targeting use household IP data that may include children's viewing?
- Can a consumer withdraw permission, and does that withdrawal reach every partner that received the data?
Source: The ADOTAT Show with Jesse Redniss, Qonsent. Also: Clean Rooms Are Sold as Privacy Protection. Qonsent's Jesse Redniss Says They Don't Clean Data.. Quotes are trimmed for filler; claims and figures are the speaker's own.
More compliance notes
- Verification Vendors Sell MFA Avoidance. TrustX's David Kohl Says Don't Outsource It to IAS and DV.
- X Sued Advertisers for Not Advertising. LUMA's Terry Kawaja Called It Comically Misguided: You Cannot Compel People to Advertise.
- Buyers Block Made-for-Advertising Sites by List. Two Ad Tech Builders on The ADOTAT Show Disagreed on Whether the Lists Are Right.
- The FTC Turned Its Endorsement Guides Into Rules. Damon Wright Says That Prices a Fake Testimonial at Up to $51,000 Per Consumer.
- Privacy Laws Are Written to Protect Consumers. TAG's Mike Zaneis Says Regulation Almost Always Helps the Biggest Incumbents.
- Verification Vendors Quote Buyers a Fraud Rate. Google's Former Fraud Lead Says Some Fraud Gets Through on Purpose.
- Brand Safety Blocklists Keep Logos Off the News. The Media Trust Says the Cheap Slots Left Behind Draw Malware.
- Programmatic Plans Promise Quality Reach. Butler/Till Found 19 Percent Made-for-Advertising Inventory in One Large Client Buy.
- The Industry Was Told to Get Ready for Privacy Sandbox. IAB Tech Lab's CEO Said It Was Somewhere Between Alpha and Beta.