Verification Vendors Sell MFA Avoidance. TrustX's David Kohl Says Don't Outsource It to IAS and DV.
By Pesach Lattin, from The ADOTAT Show
David Kohl advised NBC, Disney and the holding companies as a consultant at PwC and EY before starting TrustX, a marketplace for premium publishers. On The ADOTAT Show, the week the MFA headlines broke, he laid out why a brand cannot hand quality control to a vendor list.
What was said
- “There is zero possibility that an advertiser will truly get value from MFA, period. If you happen to believe that you're getting value from it, it's because the MFA publisher has gamed the attribution system to look like they're delivering you a return on investment.”
On made-for-advertising sites - “Don't outsource MFA to IAS and DV. These are starting points. Don't be asleep at the switch.”
On verification vendors - “As quickly as you think you've excluded something, a new one pops up. As quickly as we create a standard, the MFAs will game that standard.”
On blocklists - “I view these new forms of identity that rely on an email address as far less private, much more permanent.”
On ID solutions
Why it matters
Kohl's point is about where the record lives. A blocklist from a vendor tells you what someone else decided to exclude. An inclusion list built from your own results tells you what you chose to buy and why. If a campaign is ever questioned, the second one is the record that holds up, because it was built from evidence the brand owns. He also warned that a good-looking attribution number on cheap inventory may be the thing being gamed, not the proof that it works.
Questions to ask before you sign
- Do we buy from an inclusion list built on our own results, or only exclude from a vendor's list?
- Who decides a site is MFA in our contracts, and can we see the criteria?
- Has anyone checked whether our best-performing cheap inventory is gaming the attribution pixel?
- Which ID solutions in our stack tie to an email address, and what did the consumer actually agree to?
Source: The ADOTAT Show with David Kohl, TrustX. Also: Verification Vendors Sell MFA Protection. TrustX's David Kohl Says Don't Outsource It to IAS and DV.. Quotes are trimmed for filler; claims and figures are the speaker's own.
More compliance notes
- Clean Rooms Are Sold as Privacy Protection. Qonsent's Jesse Redniss Says Clean Rooms Don't Clean Data.
- X Sued Advertisers for Not Advertising. LUMA's Terry Kawaja Called It Comically Misguided: You Cannot Compel People to Advertise.
- Buyers Block Made-for-Advertising Sites by List. Two Ad Tech Builders on The ADOTAT Show Disagreed on Whether the Lists Are Right.
- The FTC Turned Its Endorsement Guides Into Rules. Damon Wright Says That Prices a Fake Testimonial at Up to $51,000 Per Consumer.
- Privacy Laws Are Written to Protect Consumers. TAG's Mike Zaneis Says Regulation Almost Always Helps the Biggest Incumbents.
- Verification Vendors Quote Buyers a Fraud Rate. Google's Former Fraud Lead Says Some Fraud Gets Through on Purpose.
- Brand Safety Blocklists Keep Logos Off the News. The Media Trust Says the Cheap Slots Left Behind Draw Malware.
- Programmatic Plans Promise Quality Reach. Butler/Till Found 19 Percent Made-for-Advertising Inventory in One Large Client Buy.
- The Industry Was Told to Get Ready for Privacy Sandbox. IAB Tech Lab's CEO Said It Was Somewhere Between Alpha and Beta.