Programmatic Plans Promise Quality Reach. Butler/Till Found 19 Percent Made-for-Advertising Inventory in One Large Client Buy.
By Pesach Lattin, from The ADOTAT Show
Scott Ensign is chief strategy officer at Butler/Till, an independent, employee-owned agency with deep roots in health and pharma. On The ADOTAT Show he described what his agency found when it measured one large client's programmatic buy more closely.
What was said
- “In some cases, 19 percent of what I would consider MFA inventory. Again, it's not fraud, but it's just not exactly what you would want your brands associated with.”
On a large client buy - “Honestly, I think it is really incumbent upon the SSPs to clean that up. If you're an SSP, you're creating a product.”
On who owns the cleanup - “The prime directive for a media agency is stewardship and knowing what you're buying on behalf of your clients.”
On log-level data - “There is a demand for cheap reach. You see that in things like, frankly, holdco outcome groups, where there's a transparently non-transparent aspect to what they're offering.”
On where the demand comes from
Why it matters
The 19 percent figure is the agency's own and was not independently verified. The principle Ensign set is the useful part: an agency can let a client overrule its quality standards, but it should not accept a partner that will not show log-level data. Made-for-advertising inventory is not fraud, which is exactly why it survives contracts written only about fraud.
Questions to ask before you sign
- Does our contract define made-for-advertising inventory, or only invalid traffic?
- Will every SSP and DSP in our path provide log-level data?
- How much of our programmatic spend runs through deals versus the open exchange?
- If we buy through a principal-based or outcome product, can we see where the impressions ran?
Source: The ADOTAT Show with Scott Ensign, Butler/Till. Also: Butler/Till Buys Pharma Ads. Its Strategy Chief Says the Pharma Ad Glut Helped Invite a TV Ban.. Quotes are trimmed for filler; claims and figures are the speaker's own.
More compliance notes
- Clean Rooms Are Sold as Privacy Protection. Qonsent's Jesse Redniss Says Clean Rooms Don't Clean Data.
- Verification Vendors Sell MFA Avoidance. TrustX's David Kohl Says Don't Outsource It to IAS and DV.
- X Sued Advertisers for Not Advertising. LUMA's Terry Kawaja Called It Comically Misguided: You Cannot Compel People to Advertise.
- Buyers Block Made-for-Advertising Sites by List. Two Ad Tech Builders on The ADOTAT Show Disagreed on Whether the Lists Are Right.
- The FTC Turned Its Endorsement Guides Into Rules. Damon Wright Says That Prices a Fake Testimonial at Up to $51,000 Per Consumer.
- Privacy Laws Are Written to Protect Consumers. TAG's Mike Zaneis Says Regulation Almost Always Helps the Biggest Incumbents.
- Verification Vendors Quote Buyers a Fraud Rate. Google's Former Fraud Lead Says Some Fraud Gets Through on Purpose.
- Brand Safety Blocklists Keep Logos Off the News. The Media Trust Says the Cheap Slots Left Behind Draw Malware.
- The Industry Was Told to Get Ready for Privacy Sandbox. IAB Tech Lab's CEO Said It Was Somewhere Between Alpha and Beta.