X Sued Advertisers for Not Advertising. LUMA's Terry Kawaja Called It Comically Misguided: You Cannot Compel People to Advertise.
By Pesach Lattin, from The ADOTAT Show
Terry Kawaja, founder and CEO of the investment bank LUMA Partners, recorded The ADOTAT Show on August 8, 2024, just after X announced its lawsuit claiming advertisers had conspired not to advertise on the platform. Kawaja, who went to law school, said the case misunderstood both the law and the market.
What was said
- “The lawsuit that X announced the other day was nothing short of comically misguided, because it was premised on the notion that there was a conspiracy to not advertise on Twitter and that such conspiracy violated the law. Nothing could be further from the truth if they understood the law.”
On the lawsuit - “Here is this proponent of free speech who didn't think about this other notion of free will, which is to say you cannot compel people to advertise on your platform.”
On advertiser choice - “Basically they were just the organizing faction around people making their own decisions as to where they wanted to spend.”
On GARM, the industry group at the center of the dispute - “The advertising art has plummeted. It's crap. Punch the monkey kind of 2002 digital ad quality.”
On why brands might choose to leave
Why it matters
Kawaja's view is an opinion, and the case was at its start when he gave it. The practical lesson for brands does not depend on how it ends: where you choose not to spend is a business decision, and the strongest position is one you can show was made independently. Brand safety standards, internal reviews and performance data that explain a decision are worth more than a group email that looks like a pact.
Questions to ask before you sign
- Can we show that each decision to pause or exclude a platform was made independently, with our own reasons on file?
- What do we say in industry groups and shared channels about specific platforms, and who reviews it?
- Do our brand safety standards spell out the criteria we apply, so a decision traces back to them?
- Does counsel review participation in any industry initiative that coordinates on ad placement?
Source: The ADOTAT Show with Terence Kawaja, LUMA Partners. Also: What Terry Kawaja said on the episode, on adotat.com. Quotes are trimmed for filler; claims and figures are the speaker's own.
More compliance notes
- Clean Rooms Are Sold as Privacy Protection. Qonsent's Jesse Redniss Says Clean Rooms Don't Clean Data.
- Verification Vendors Sell MFA Avoidance. TrustX's David Kohl Says Don't Outsource It to IAS and DV.
- Buyers Block Made-for-Advertising Sites by List. Two Ad Tech Builders on The ADOTAT Show Disagreed on Whether the Lists Are Right.
- The FTC Turned Its Endorsement Guides Into Rules. Damon Wright Says That Prices a Fake Testimonial at Up to $51,000 Per Consumer.
- Privacy Laws Are Written to Protect Consumers. TAG's Mike Zaneis Says Regulation Almost Always Helps the Biggest Incumbents.
- Verification Vendors Quote Buyers a Fraud Rate. Google's Former Fraud Lead Says Some Fraud Gets Through on Purpose.
- Brand Safety Blocklists Keep Logos Off the News. The Media Trust Says the Cheap Slots Left Behind Draw Malware.
- Programmatic Plans Promise Quality Reach. Butler/Till Found 19 Percent Made-for-Advertising Inventory in One Large Client Buy.
- The Industry Was Told to Get Ready for Privacy Sandbox. IAB Tech Lab's CEO Said It Was Somewhere Between Alpha and Beta.